| Round 1 | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1.1 | Fla | Evan Longoria |
| 1.2 | Tex | Jay Bruce |
| 1.3 | Tex | Clayton Kershaw |
| 1.4 | SF | Travis Snider |
| 1.5 | Det | Alexi Ramirez |
| 1.6 | StL | Chris Davis |
| 1.7 | Cle | Armando Galarraga |
| 1.8 | Tor | Brandon Wood |
| 1.9 | KC | Johnny Cueto |
| 1.10 | Oak | Ian Stewart |
| 1.11 | Bal | Chris Volstad |
| 1.12 | Det | Chase Headley |
| 1.13 | Min | Max Scherzer |
| 1.14 | LA | Mike Aviles |
| 1.15 | Atl | Jeff Clement |
| 1.16 | SF | Gio Gonzalez |
| 1.17 | Col | Jed Lowrie |
| 1.18 | CWS | Carlos Gonzalez |
| 1.19 | Pit | Pablo Sandoval |
| 1.20 | Bal | Kosuke Fukudome |
| 1.21 | Sea | Greg Smith |
| 1.22 | Pit | Luke Hochevar |
| 1.23 | SD | Nick Blackburn |
| 1.24 | NYY | Hiroki Kuroda |
| Round 2 | ||
| 2.1 | Cin | Ryan Sweeney |
| 2.2 | Col | Sean Gallagher |
| 2.3 | SD | Denard Span |
| 2.4 | Ana | Jose Arredondo |
| 2.5 | Col | Justin Masterson |
| 2.6 | StL | Shin Soo-Choo |
| 2.7 | Cle | Corey Wade |
| 2.8 | Sea | Grant Balfour |
| 2.9 | KC | John Baker |
| 2.10 | Oak | Dana Eveland |
| 2.11 | Bal | Collin Balester |
| 2.12 | Det | Joey Devine |
| 2.13 | Min | Blake DeWitt |
| 2.14 | Tex | Jorge Campillo |
| 2.15 | Atl | Chris Perez |
| 2.16 | SF | Matt Antonelli |
| 2.17 | Col | Ben Francisco |
| 2.18 | CWS | Jeff Samadzija |
| 2.19 | Pit | Matt Joyce |
| 2.20 | NYY | Mike Adams |
| 2.21 | Sea | Jerry Hairston Jr |
| 2.22 | Mil | Gabe Kapler |
| 2.23 | SD | Gregor Blanco |
| 2.24 | NYY | Nick Hundley |
| Round 3 | ||
| 3.1 | Fla | Brandon Moss |
| 3.2 | Was | Ramon A. Ramirez |
| 3.3 | Sea | Matt Thornton |
| 3.4 | SF | Joel Hanrahan |
| 3.5 | NYY | Joe Inglett |
| 3.6 | StL | Jim Johnson |
| 3.7 | Cle | Jody Gerut |
| 3.8 | Tor | Ian Kennedy |
| 3.9 | KC | Emmanuel Burris |
| 3.10 | Oak | Ramon S. Ramirez |
| 3.11 | Bal | JR Towles |
| 3.12 | Cin | Matt Harrison |
| 3.13 | Min | Daniel Murphy |
| 3.14 | SF | Jeff Karstens |
| 3.15 | Atl | Wladimir Balentin |
| 3.16 | SF | Eugenio Velez |
| 3.17 | Col | Frank Francisco |
| 3.18 | CWS | Jessie Carlson |
| 3.19 | Pit | Charlie Morton |
| 3.20 | Tor | Brian Buscher |
| 3.21 | Oak | Brian Barton |
| 3.22 | Pit | Emilio Bonifacio |
| 3.23 | SD | Jeff Bennett |
| 3.24 | Oak | Craig Breslow |
| Round 4 | ||
| 4.1 | Fla | Jeremy Reed |
| 4.2 | Was | Sergio Romo |
| 4.3 | Tex | Willy Aybar |
| 4.4 | Was | Brad Ziegler |
| 4.5 | Was | Alfredo Aceves |
| 4.6 | StL | Edwar Ramirez |
| 4.7 | Cle | Brandon Boggs |
| 4.8 | Tor | Anderson Hernandez |
| 4.9 | KC | Scott Feldman |
| 4.10 | NYY | Joe Nelson |
| 4.11 | Bal | David Purcey |
| 4.12 | Col | Fernando Tatis |
| 4.13 | Min | Ben Zobrist |
| 4.14 | LA | Chris Dickerson |
| 4.15 | Atl | JA Happ |
| 4.16 | SF | Clayton Richard |
| 4.17 | Col | Luis Rodriguez |
| 4.18 | Oak | Brent Lillibridge |
| 4.19 | Pit | Greg Reynolds |
| 4.20 | Phi | Steven Shell |
| 4.21 | Sea | Ryan Tucker |
| 4.22 | Mil | Will Ohman |
| 4.23 | SD | Kyle McClellan |
| 4.24 | Det | Bill Bray |
| Round 5 | ||
| 5.1 | Fla | John Bowker |
| 5.2 | Ana | David Robertson |
| 5.3 | Tex | Fernando Perez |
| 5.4 | Ana | Nick Evans |
| 5.5 | Phi | Brandon Jones |
| 5.6 | StL | Dennis Sarfate |
| 5.7 | Cle | Luis Montanez |
| 5.8 | Tor | Bryan LaHair |
| 5.9 | Fla | Roy Corcoran |
| 5.10 | Oak | Garrett Mock |
| 5.11 | Bal | Doug Waechter |
| 5.12 | Det | Joe Mather |
| 5.13 | Min | Chin-Lung Hu |
| 5.14 | LA | Greg Norton |
| 5.15 | Atl | Mitchell Boggs |
| 5.16 | SF | Travis Ishikawa |
| 5.17 | Col | Brian Moehler |
| 5.18 | SF | Aaron Cunningham |
| 5.19 | Pit | Seth Smith |
| 5.20 | Phi | Brian Bixler |
| 5.21 | Oak | Wesley Wright |
| 5.22 | Mil | Dan Giese |
| 5.23 | SD | Jerry Blevins |
| 5.24 | NYY | Micah Hoffpauir |
| Round 6 | ||
| 6.1 | Fla | Sean Burnett |
| 6.2 | Was | Brett Gardner |
| 6.3 | Tex | Logan Kensing |
| 6.4 | Ana | Chan Ho Park |
| 6.5 | Phi | Jeff Larish |
| 6.6 | StL | Phil Dumatrait |
| 6.7 | Cle | Cesar Jimenez |
| 6.8 | Tor | Juan Rivera |
| 6.9 | KC | Edgar Gonzalez |
| 6.10 | Oak | Josh Geer |
| 6.11 | Bal | Aquilino Lopez |
| 6.12 | Det | Matt Tolbert |
| 6.13 | Min | Zach Jackson |
| 6.14 | LA | Ramon Santiago |
| 6.15 | Atl | Dennys Reyes |
| 6.16 | SF | Mitch Stetter |
| 6.17 | Col | Russell Branyan |
| 6.18 | CWS | Freddie Dolsi |
| 6.19 | Pit | Sean Rodriguez |
| 6.20 | Phi | Ramon Troncosco |
| 6.21 | Bal | Jose Veras |
| 6.22 | Mil | German Duran |
| 6.23 | SD | Henry Blanco |
| 6.24 | Oak | Clay Condrey |
| Round 7 | ||
| 7.1 | Fla | Josh Banks |
| 7.2 | Was | Clete Thomas |
| 7.3 | Tex | Blaine Boyer |
| 7.4 | Ana | Brian N. Anderson |
| 7.5 | Cin | Kevin Hart |
| 7.6 | StL | Glendon Rusch |
| 7.7 | Cle | Joaquin Arias |
| 7.8 | Phi | Mark Lowe |
| 7.9 | KC | Mike Lincoln |
| 7.10 | Cle | Wil Nieves |
| 7.11 | Bal | Billy Sadler |
| 7.12 | Det | Eric Stults |
| 7.13 | Min | Ryan Hanigan |
| 7.14 | LA | Keiichi Yabu |
| 7.15 | Atl | Brandon League |
| 7.16 | SF | Dan Meyer |
| 7.17 | Col | Dewayne Wise |
| 7.18 | Cin | Warner Madrigal |
| 7.19 | Pit | Mike Hampton |
| 7.20 | Fla | Toby Hall |
| 7.21 | Sea | Kevin Cash |
| 7.22 | Det | Kory Casto |
| 7.23 | SD | Will Venable |
| 7.24 | Col | Josh Outman |